5. My Maudlin Career by Camera Obscura

☆ standout track → “French Navy”
pitchfork — 8.3/10
Camera Obscura fans will be pleased to know that she’s still turning out maudlin torch songs with apparent ease. It is a record of the most immoderate sentiment: Thirty seconds in, on “French Navy”, you’ve already got a dusty library, a French sailor, and the moon on the silvery lake. By the second track, “The Sweetest Thing”, Campbell’s ready to trade her mother for a compliment from a certain someone. She might not want to be sad again, but judging from the kind of tangled romantic assignations she confesses to here? Album number five already lurks in the inevitable fallout.
paste magazine — 89/100
My Maudlin Career is 45 minutes-plus of blissed-out orchestral indie pop, enlivened with classic Motownisms and overflowing with silvery tones as singer/guitarist Tracyanne Campbell unspools her lazy, entrancing croon and clever-cute rhymes across a night of innocence regained. Liquid-soul surf guitar and dreamy organ work are punctuated by tiny, chiming glockenspiel hits, wrapped snugly in a blanket of twee, placed gently in a Belle & Sebastianet and set afloat on the River Reverb, waiting for some pharaoh’s daughter to fish the precious little bundle out of the cattails. My Maudlin Career is anything but—sure, it’s sentimental, but never effusively. It’s an infectious album that blooms repeatedly throughout, unfolding in muted, endearing aural hues; simultaneously sad and celebratory, and always charming.
4. Bitte Orca by The Dirty Projectors

☆ standout track → “Cannibal Resource”
paste magazine — 89/100
Utilizing his bandmates as instruments, he dispatches guitarist Amber Coffman on a Mariah Carey-styled slow jam entitled “Stillness is the Move” and bassist Angel Deradoorian for the fragile balladry of “Two Doves,” their voices allowing Longstreth to experiment with a different type of pop arrangement. The Led Zep-ish swagger of “Cannibal Resource” and the dizzying harmonies and stuttering backbeats of “Temecula Sunrise” are more typical of his contrapuntal sense of composition, though he seems to be gaining confidence in his ability to cut directly to the listener instead of obscuring his melodies with constant thematic and structural shifts. The result is the most thoroughly engaging entry in the Dirty Projectors catalog and one of the most singularly engrossing albums likely to be released this year, a triumph in sustained creative restlessness.
pitchfork — 9.2/10
The key is that, rather surprisingly, Bitte Orca is one of the more purely enjoyable indie-rock records in an awfully long time; remarkable by any means, but even moreso considering the source. It’s breezy without a hint of slightness, tuneful but with its fair share of tumult, concise and inventive and replayable and plain old fun. It is the sound of Longstreth the composer and Longstreth the pop songwriter finally settling on a few things together after years of tug-of-war between the two.
3. Riceboy Sleeps by Jónsi & Alex

☆ standout track → “Boy 1904”
pitchfork — 5.3/10
Put together, Riceboy Sleeps is an admirable, intensely personal labor of love from a guy who’s risking risibility by the mere matter of including the word “sleep” in its title, and although “Daníell in the Sea” and “All the Big Trees” do little remarkable on their own merits, when combined with the arresting videos found on the Riceboy Sleeps website, you start to understand its motivation more thoroughly. And really, as long as you don’t give it your undivided attention, Riceboy Sleeps can keep you company in your cubicle or gridlock traffic, though I realize that’s not exactly as riveting as “if there’s one ambient album you own this year…!” But in a necessarily faceless artistic milieu, a Sigur Rós Stamp of Approval might make that the case anyway.
paste magazine — 83/100
Where Sigur Rós drew minimalist lines, Riceboy Sleeps paints sweeping landscapes with fully fleshed out layers of sound, sans lyrics. Film-score comparisons are inevitable; “All The Big Trees,” especially, has an awful lot in common with the melody threaded throughout The Diving Bell and the Butterfly. [...] The album flows seamlessly from one track to the next, from the lighter “Indian Summer,” which floats by without any arresting change, to the dark “Boy 1904,” which opens with a stunning barely-there choir and closes with chilling footsteps and a door slam. “Atlas Song” is more haunting, with a ghostly chorus of warbly young voices and a trapped-underwater feel.
2. The Hazards of Love by The Decemberists

☆ standout track → “The Wanting Comes in Waves/Repaid”
antiquiet — ★★★★★
I got my copy a week ago, and according to iTunes, I’ve listened to it twenty times. I didn’t start to understand the story until at least the tenth or eleventh run through, so part of me just wanted to sort it out on paper. But what you need to know is that this is the best album of 2009 so far. It’s a masterpiece, and The Decemberists have outdone their amazing Crane Wife against all odds. It’s a grand, inspired vision. It’s a concept album, but not the usual sort, where the story or cliché being milked for an album’s worth of lyrics is more of an excuse than a constitutive instrument. Go. Get it now.
pitchfork — 5.7/10
Nobody got into the Decemberists for the riffs. In other ways, though, the theatrical Portland folk-rockers’ noble sojourn into heavy narrative prog-folk was probably always in the stars. Ornately antiquarian diction was their Ziggy Stardust. Ginormous song suites based on world folklore were their deaf, dumb, and blind kid. Yes, they were meant for The Wall.
1. Manners by Passion Pit

☆ standout track → “The Reeling”
pitchfork — 8.1/10
Even if the rock kids aren’t doing the standing still as much these days, indie-friendly electro-pop bands are still liable to have their own backs against the wall– Hot Chip with their Urkel affectations, Junior Boys’ overriding permafrost, Cut Copy and their unflappable cool. Despite residing on the always trustworthy Frenchkiss, Passion Pit aren’t cool. Their approach to danceable rock music is more Friday night than year-end-list. It’s also distinctly, for a lack of a better term, American.
paste magazine — 92/100
In the last several years, the indie universe has expanded—shambling white-guy rock will always have its place, but dance music now occupies the same hipster-certified space. No new band connects the dots better than Passion Pit, a Boston-area quintet with a giddy melodic sense and an unabashed love for synth pop.